Inspired by the two probes currently giving us unprecedented views of our star, I recently started to wonder just how close we could get to the surface of the Sun. Could we one day penetrate the outer layers of the star and beam back readings of the extreme conditions that must lie just under the surface? The answer is probably no, at least for now, but we can almost certainly get much closer than our best attempts so far.
Can We Touch the Sun?
If we want to get close to the Sun — and for the sake of this question we do — we’re going to need something that can withstand a lot of heat. There are plenty of known materials, and presumably even more unknown ones, that make good candidates for this. But let’s keep things simple, and go with tungsten.
On the face of it, tungsten is unremarkable. Like many metals, it has a silvery appearance. On Earth it is rare — yet useful enough to be found in everyday life, for example, in light bulbs or in electronics. But in one way tungsten stands apart. Of all the elements, tungsten has the highest melting point, staying solid until 6192°F (3422°C).
So let’s build a spacecraft entirely from tungsten, and ignore all the impracticalities that come with doing that. Our probe will simply be a solid sphere of metal measuring two meters across (roughly six feet, the height of a tall man). We’ll build several of them, and they’ll launch together, before heading into different orbits around the Sun.
Our first probe will settle into a comfortable circular orbit twenty-five million miles from our star. Here, close to the innermost planet Mercury, the Sun starts to heat up the tungsten sphere. Metals are shiny, which helps, as two-thirds of the heat is immediately reflected away.
And, as the spacecraft warms up, it starts emitting heat of its own. The hotter it gets, the more heat it radiates away. At some point, if it doesn’t melt first, it will radiate away exactly as much heat as it receives from the Sun. We’ll call this the sphere’s equilibrium temperature, and it represents the greatest temperature the Sun can heat our spacecraft to.
Close to Mercury, the probe’s equilibrium temperature will be 310°F (155°C). The spacecraft would be hot to touch, but nowhere near melting yet. We can definitely get closer.
The second probe does that, this time settling ten million miles from our star. The Sun feels hotter here, but, at a temperature of 760°F (405°C), our tungsten sphere is still not even close to melting. Though isn’t yet be a problem for tungsten, it is for the expensive electronics that power most satellites. If we wanted to send a probe this close to the Sun, we’d need some sophisticated cooling systems to keep them running.
The Parker Solar Probe, launched by NASA, will make its closest approach to the Sun on December 24th, 2024. On that day the spacecraft will be just four million miles from the star, the closest any man-made object has ever been. Closest, that is, until our third probe reaches its destination. We’re going to beat the Parker Solar Probe by a fraction, and orbit 3.9 million miles from the Sun.
This probe is going to get scorching hot, reaching 1500°F (815°C). It’s lucky we don’t have any sensors or computers on board, because at this temperature they would fail in seconds. The Parker Solar Probe will face similar temperatures, but it won’t stay close to the Sun for long.
Its orbit has been designed so that the probe whips around the Sun at high speed (travelling more than 120 miles every second), before heading to more temperate regions close to Venus. This, together with a heat-resistant shield and high-tech cooling systems, help the probe survive such torrid temperatures.
Our tungsten probe is nothing more than a metal sphere, and has no expensive electronics to worry about. We can go closer, and we will. But, as we get nearer to the Sun, there’s another issue we need to consider. The Sun itself has a diameter of 860,000 miles, and at four million miles, we’re still pretty far from the surface. But surrounding the Sun, and extending out into space for millions of miles, is the stellar corona, a region of plasma that reaches extreme temperatures.
What makes the corona so hot is still not fully understood. Scientists believe that the intense magnetic fields around the Sun have something to do with it. What exactly that is, though, is an area of active research. The Parker Solar Probe, which will pass through the solar corona, hopes to shed some light on this mystery.
The Sun follows an eleven-year cycle, during which the strength of the corona rises and falls. During quiet years the extent of the corona is limited, but it returns with a vengeance during active years. And even during quiet years, the Sun occasionally hurls vast quantities of superhot plasma into space. The energy and radiation contained in one of these bursts would almost certainly be fatal for any spacecraft.
We want to get as close to the Sun as possible, so let’s pick a quiet year for our mission. For now we’ll stick with a circular orbit, but we’ll orientate it so that it passes over the poles of the Sun, where the corona is much weaker. We’ll also take advantage of the low density of the stellar corona — even though it is extremely hot, the particles that carry that heat are widely spread out. This means our probe will heat up more slowly than you might expect.
After all this, our spacecraft, at a distance of one million miles from the Sun, heats up to over 3,000°F (1700°C). That’s hot enough to melt lead, but not yet enough to destroy our plucky tungsten sphere. With clever engineering, we could design a heat shield and enough cooling to send a real probe to this distance, if only for a short time.
To go closer, we’ll need to skim the surface of the Sun. Our next probe will fly to just above the photosphere, the outer layer of the star. Now we are facing two difficult challenges. Heat is a big and obvious one. At this point the high temperatures will prove too much even for tungsten to endure for long. But another is the high amount of radiation coming from the Sun — which will be deadly for any electronics onboard.
But let’s head there anyway, and see what happens. It’s hard to judge exactly how hot our probe will get, but it’s probably in the region of 10,000°F (5,000°C). This is more than enough to melt the sphere, and almost certainly enough to vaporise what’s left. Even if we managed to magically cool our probe to absolute zero before arrival, it would survive no more than fifteen minutes.
This then, seems to be the limit of our endurance. Even the toughest element on Earth, tungsten, can’t bear to touch the Sun for more than a few minutes. And that is just considering heat — the radiation emitted by the nuclear explosions that power our star are positively deadly for any spacecraft that gets too close.
It’s a safe bet to say that the limit on how close we can get to the Sun is somewhere around a million miles, at least based on modern technology. It may be that future engineers come up with exotic solutions that allow travel to extreme places, to the very surface or even inside the Sun. But for now, although we may not be able to quite touch the Sun, we can still get pretty close.
So much reporting around health, science and space exploration is unrealistic, hyperbolic and misleading. These are complicated topics, and there are often no easy or straight forward answers. Instead what is needed is analysis, discussion and an exploration of the possible ways forward.
Follow me on Medium and subscribe to my free Substack newsletter to get the latest. Articles are published regularly, and by signing up you will never miss an update.